Guy in response to your items, I acknowledge that this is very much just a starting point for discussion and therefore the comments are welcomed.
I allocated the points purely as an instinctual/gut feeling based on my experience of the documents. The reasoning behind the varying points for the censuses was that each has a varying number of data points, and therefore more items that can be cross referenced against other evidence. As such if points were subtracted for inconsistencies then logically the later census documents have more chance of having those deductions than the earlier censuses.
I think this is why percentages are dangerous because you will have the potential to achieve 90% plus and in reality this could never be the case.
However if an individual has more documentation to support their existence and this data correlates with other sources then it would just visually display as a higher score. This would highlight potential weaker links in the ancestral line at a glance.
Your item number 7 is a similar approach but awarding points or accuracy rather than deducting them for inaccuracies
- Forum
- Family History
- General Family History Queries
- Determining Certainty
Results 21 to 21 of 21
Thread: Determining Certainty
-
30-10-2018, 1:50 PM #21Starting to feel at home
- Join Date
- Sep 2013
- Location
- West Midlands
- Posts
- 47
Quick Navigation
General Family History Queries
Top
- Site Areas
- Settings
- Private Messages
- Subscriptions
- Who's Online
- Search Forums
- Forums Home
- Forums
- Special Offers
- Finding Your Feet on the Brit-Gen Forums
- Family History
- Acronyms and Abbreviations
- Brickwalls
- British Census
- Certificates - Births, Marriages and Deaths in the UK
- DNA Research
- Family History Societies
- Genealogy Beginners
- General Family History Queries
- Recommended Books
- Strays
- Success stories.
- Surname Interests
- Unwanted Certificates
- Unwanted Wills
- Useful Information & Tips
- Useful Online Sources
- Writing up your family history
- Topics
- Adoption Pre 1911
- Black Sheep
- Catholic Records
- Church Registers
- Court Records
- Divorce
- Electoral Rolls
- Emigration
- IGI
- Illegitimacy
- Institutions
- Jewish Roots
- Medical
- Newspapers and Magazines
- Non Conformist Records
- One Name Studies
- One Place Studies
- Parish Law
- Reading old documents
- Romanies
- Schools
- Wills
- Occupations
- Occupations - general forum
- Actors & Artistes
- Apprentices
- Bakers
- Canals and Watermen
- Carpenters, Wheelwrights, etc.
- Clergymen
- Coastguards and Customs Officers (Preventive Men)
- Cordwainers, Shoemakers, Saddlers, etc.
- Husbandmen, Yeoman, etc.
- Labourers
- Licensed Victuallers, Innkeepers, etc.
- Mariners and Ships
- Medical Occupations
- Military - Army
- Military - Royal Air Force
- Military - Royal Navy & Royal Marines
- Military - General
- Miners
- Policemen
- Photographers and old photographs
- Railwaymen
- Smiths
- Stone Masons & Builders
- Tailors and Dressmakers.
- Teachers
- History Topics
- Medieval Period - Roughly (500-1500)
- Tudor and Jacobean England (c1500-1625)
- The Normans (1066 onwards)
- English Civil War - (1642-1649) (commonwealth & Protectorate 1644-1659)
- The Georgian Period - (1714-1830) though could run to 1837
- American War of Independence - (1775-1783)
- Napoleonic Wars - (1804-1815)
- The Victorian Period - (1837-1901) though this could run from 1832
- The Crimean War - (1854-1856)
- American Civil War - (1861-1865)
- Boer Wars - (1880-1881) & (1899-1902) suggest (1880-1902)
- WW1 1914-1918
- WW2 1939-1945
- Post WWII
- County Forums including Ireland, Scotland, Wales and British Islands.
- England - Counties (Chapman Code - ENG)
- General English Family History
- Bedfordshire (Chapman Code - BDF)
- Berkshire (Chapman Code - BRK)
- Buckinghamshire (Chapman Code - BKM)
- Cambridgeshire (Chapman Code - CAM)
- Cheshire (Chapman Code - CHS)
- Cornwall (Chapman Code - Con)
- Cumbria (Chapman Code - CMA)
- Derbyshire (Chapman Code - DBY)
- Devonshire (Chapman Code - DEV)
- Dorset (Chapman Code - DOR)
- Durham (Chapman Code - DUR)
- Essex (Chapman Code - ESS)
- Gloucestershire (Chapman Code - GLS)
- Hampshire and the Isle of Wight (Chapman Codes - HAM & IOW)
- Herefordshire Chapman Code - HEF)
- Hertfordshire (Chapman Code - HRT)
- Huntingdonshire (Chapman Code - HUN)
- Kent (Chapman Code - KEN)
- Lancashire (Chapman Code LAN)
- Leicestershire (Chapman Code - LEI)
- Lincolnshire (Chapman Code - LIN)
- London (Chapman Code - LND)
- Middlesex (Chapman Code - MDX)
- Norfolk (Chapman Code - NFK)
- Northamptonshire (Chapman Code - NTH)
- Northumberland (Chapman Code - NBL)
- Nottinghamshire (Chapman Code - NTT)
- Oxfordshire (Chapman Code - OXF)
- Rutland (Chapman Code - RUT)
- Shropshire (Chapman Code - SAL)
- Somerset (Chapman Code - SOM)
- Staffordshire (Chapman Code - STS)
- Suffolk (Chapman Code - SFK)
- Surrey (Chapman Code - SRY)
- Sussex (Chapman Code - SSX)
- Warwickshire (Chapman Code - WAR)
- Westmorland (Chapman Code - WES)
- Wiltshire (Chapman Code - WIL)
- Worcestershire (Chapman Code - WOR)
- Yorkshire (Chapman Code - YKS)
- Ireland - Counties (Chapman Code - IRL)
- General Irish Family History
- County Antrim (Chapman Code - ANT)
- County Armagh (Chapman Code - ARM)
- County Cavan (Chapman Code - CAV)
- County Clare (Chapman Code - CLA)
- County Cork (Chapman Code - COR)
- County Donegal (Chapman Code - DON)
- County Down (Chapman Code - DOW)
- Dublin (Chapman Code - DUB)
- County Fermanagh (Chapman Code - FER)
- County Galway (Chapman Code - GAL)
- County Kerry (Chapman Code - KER)
- County Kildare (Chapman Code - KID)
- County Kilkenny (Chapman Code - KIK)
- County Laois (Chapman Code - LEX)
- County Limerick (Chapman Code - LIM)
- County Mayo (Chapman Code - MAY)
- County Monaghan (Chapman Code - MOG)
- County Offaly (Kings) (Chapman Code - OFF)
- County Sligo (Chapman Code - SLI)
- County Tipperary (Chapman Code - TIP)
- County Tyrone (Chapman Code - TYR)
- County Waterford (Chapman Code - WAT)
- County Wexford (Chapman Code - WEX)
- County Wicklow (Chapman Code - WIC)
- Scotland - Counties (Chapman Code - SCT)
- General Scottish Family History
- Aberdeenshire (Chapman Code - ABD)
- Angus (Chapman Code - ANS)
- Argyll (Chapman Code - ARL)
- Ayrshire (Chapman Code - AYR)
- Banffshire (Chapman Code - BAN)
- Berwickshire (Chapman Code - BEW)
- Caithness (Chapman Code - CAI)
- Clackmannanshire (Chapman CODE - CLK)
- Dumfriesshire (Chapman Code - DFS)
- Dunbartonshire (Chapman Code - DNB)
- East Lothian (Chapman Code - ELN)
- Fife (Chapman Code - FIF)
- Inverness-shire (Chapman Code - INV)
- Kincardineshire (Chapman Code - KCD)
- Kinross-shire (Chapman Code - KRS)
- Kirkcudbrightshire (Chapman Code - KKD)
- Lanarkshire (Chapman Code - LKS)
- Midlothian (Chaoman Code - MLN)
- Moray (Chapman Code - MOR)
- Orkney (Chapman Code - OKI)
- Peebleshire (Chapman Code - PEE)
- Perthshire (Chapman Code - PER)
- Renfrewshire (Chapman Code - RFW)
- Ross and Cromarty (Chapman Code - ROC)
- Roxburghshire (Chapman Code - ROX)
- Selkirkshire (Chapman Code - SEL)
- Shetland (Chapman Code - SHI)
- Stirlingshire (Chapman Code - STI)
- Sutherland (Chapman Code - SUT)
- Western Isles (Chapman Code - WIS)
- Wigtonshire (Chapman Code - WIG)
- Wales - Counties (Chapman Code - WAL)
- General Welsh Family History
- Anglesey (Chapman Code - AGY)
- Breconshire (Chapman Code - BRE)
- Caernarvonshire (Chapman Code - CAE)
- Cardiganshire (Chapman Code - CGN)
- Carmarthenshire (Chapman Code - CMN)
- Denbighshire (Chapman CODE - DEN)
- Flintshire (Chapman Code - FLN)
- Glamorgan (Chapman Code - GLA)
- Merionethshire (Chapman Code - MER)
- Monmouthshire (Chapman Code - MON)
- Montgomeryshire (Chapman Code - MGY)
- Pembrokeshire (Chapman Code - PEM)
- Radnorshire (Chapman Code - RAD)
- British Islands
- Across 'The Pond(s)' Forums
- England - Counties (Chapman Code - ENG)
- Competitions
- Brit Gen Service and Support
- Other Stuff
- FREE Resources
- Software and Computing
- Family History Fairs and Events
Helping you trace your British Family History & British Genealogy.
All times are GMT. The time now is 3:44 AM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.5
Copyright © 2024 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved.
Bookmarks