I figured that rather than post bits and pieces all over the forum, that it would be easier to make a list of all the names, where they came from and the last known ancestor I've tracked. So here goes:

Surname: McFIE/McFEE/McPHIE/McPHEE
Locality: Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: James McFie b.1725 Ayr (Sp. Eleanor Anderson)

Surname: SMITH
Locality: Ochiltree, Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: James Smith b.1646 Ochiltree (Sp. Janet Robb)

Surname: ROBB
Locality: Ochiltree, Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: Janet Robb b.1650 Ochiltree (Sp. James Smith)

Surname: ANDERSON
Locality: Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: John Anderson b.1669 Ayrshire (Sp. Marion Smith)

Surname: HUNTER
Locality: Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: John Hunter b.1680 Ayrshire (Sp. Elizabeth Skirven)

Surname: SKIRVEN
Locality: Poss. Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: Elizabeth Skirven b.1684 (Sp. John Hunter)

Surname: McCULLOCH/McCOLLOCH
Locality: poss. Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: Sarah/Sandra McCulloch (Sp. Alexander McFie)

Surname: FYFE/FIFE
Locality: Largs of Airlie, Ayshire, Scotland
Last Known: John Fyfe b.1778 Largs of Airlie (Sp. Ann Hendry)

Surname: HENDRY
Locality: Largs of Airlie, Ayshire, Scotland
Last Known: Ann Hendry b.1782 Largs of Airlie (Sp. John Fyfe)

Surname: GORDON
Locality: Rothesay, Bute, Scotland
Last Known: Joseph Gordon b.1795 Rothesay (Sp. Grizel Ferguson)

Surname: FERGUSON
Locality: Rothesay, Bute, Scotland
Last Known: Grizel Ferguson b.abt 1790 Rothesay (Sp. Joseph Gordon)

Surname: WILSON
Locality: Unsure
Last Known: Ann Sophia Wilson d.1910 Goolwa South Australia (Sp. John Gordon) *father poss. William Wilson

Surname: SMITH
Locality: Maybole, Ayrshire, Scotland (Possibly Ireland previously)
Last Known: Charles Smith b.abt 1830 Maybole (Sp. Mary Ann Smith)

Surname: SMITH
Locality: Maybole, Ayrshire, Scotland
Last Known: Mary Ann Smith b.abt 1830 Maybole (Sp. Charles Smith)

Surname: GUTTERSON
Locality: Unsure - Poss. London or Channel Islands
Last Known: James Henry Gutterson b.1855 (Sp. Mary Jane Jackson)
*father James Henry Gutterson also - locality unknown

Surname: MASSEY
Locality: Unsure - Poss. London, Channel Islands or France
Last Known: Jane Massey b.abt 1830 (Sp. James Henry Gutterson)

Surname: JACKSON
Locality: Chipping Norton, Oxfordshire, England
Last Known: James Jackson b.abt 1845 Chipping Norton (Sp. Ellen Smith)

Surname: SMITH
Locality: Chipping Norton, Oxfordshire, England
Last Known: Thomas Smith b.1813 Chipping Norton (Sp. Sarah Artis)

Surname: ARTIS/ARTISS/ARTOS/ARTER/ARTHURS
Locality: Oxfordshire, Engalnd
Last Known: John Arthur d.1722 Chilson (Sp. Elizabeth Busby)

Surname: BUSBY
Locality: Oxfordshire, England
Last Known: Elizabeth Busby b.1660 Wescote Barton? (Sp. John Arthur)

Surname: HANEL
Locality: Oxfordshire, England
Last Known: Ann Hanel b.1710 Shorthampton (Sp. John Arter)

Surname: GREEN
Locality: Unsure - possibly Oxfordshire, England
Last Known: Ann Green b.1743 (Sp. John Artos)

Surname: SMITH
Locality: Unsure - possibly Oxfordshire, England
Last Known: Jane Smith (sp. John Artiss)

Surname: WIGNELL/WIGNALL
Locality: Lancashire, England
Last Known: Thomas Wignell b.1822 Preston (Sp. Mary Ann Summerell)

Surname: SUMMERELL/SUMMERILL/SOMMERELL/SUMMERHILL
Locality: Gloucestershire, England
Last Known: William Summerell b.1711 Siston (Sp. Mary Frigg)

Surname: FRIGG
Locality: Gloucestershire, England
Last Known: Mary Frigg b.1707 Siston (Sp. William Summerell)
*Parents William and Sarah

Surname: BRITTON
Locality: Gloucestershire, England
Last Known: Betty Britton b.abt 1730 (Sp. William Summerell)

Surname: WEBB
Locality: Unsure
Last Known: Mary Webb b.1794 (Sp. Charles Summerell)
*Transported to NSW in approx. 1816

Surname: SUTHERLAND
Locality: Sutherlandshire, Scotland
Last Known: William Sutherland b.1760 Clyne (Sp. Mary Ann Sutherland)

Surname: McKAY
Locality: Sutherlandshire, Scotland
Last Known: John McKay b.1778 Loth (Sp. Margaret)

Surname: BANNERMAN
Locality: Sutherlandshire, Scotland
Last Known: Dugald Bannerman b.1803 Lothbeg (Sp. Mary Wilson)

Surname: WILSON
Locality: Sutherlandshire, Scotland
Last Known: Mary Wilson b.1807 Lothbeg (Sp. Dugald Bannerman)